Beware of tutors and their pupils baring great intellectual gifts.Heloise (1101-1164) and Peter (Pierre) Abelard (1079-1142) were two of the greatest thinkers of their day who were student and tutor, lovers and soul mates. Their love story is one of the most poignant of all time. Their affair began with passion, progressed to tragedy, and finally ended in devoted and eternal love. Nearly 1000 years since their deaths, visitors to Paris can go to a crypt which is said to be the final resting place of the lovers.
Peter Abelard was a philosopher and theologian. He was born in a small village in Brittany in France and was of the lesser nobility. He could have been a knight, but he chose instead to become a scholar. His battles would not be on the battle fields but in the cathedral schools of the time. The concept of the university was just on the horizon in Abelard’s day, but not quite developed. He was a great debater, and his reasoning often caused him to have very serious brushes with the church. He was even accused of heresy.
Peter Abelard was a wondering scholar. Drawing crowds, he debated almost everywhere he went. He arrived in Paris where he became even more renowned. He was feted by his admirers and envied by his enemies. At the same time a young woman who was about 20 years his junior was also growing in fame because of her intellectual abilities. Her name was Heloise.
Though not quite 20, Heloise had already gained attention and praise for her aptitude in languages, reading, writing, and philosophy. Abelard heard about her and was anxious to meet this prodigy. He may have been attracted to the idea of meeting a woman who was on his level or at least he desired a meeting to observe such a curiosity. In an age when the majority of people could not read or write, the few who could were men. That Heloise could, and was functioning on a level as high as Abelard, was truly remarkable.
Heloise may have been born illegitimate. She was being raised by her uncle who was a canon named Fulbert. Some believe she may have been Fulbert's daughter since their relationship was more like parent and child than uncle and niece. Canon Fulbert was determined that his niece get the best education that money could buy. He hired Peter Abelard to tutor her. It may have been love at first sight for Heloise and Abelard. Though 30, Peter Abelard had never been with a woman. His learning and thirst for knowledge had occupied most of his time. Now he was wildly and recklessly in love with his pupil. Both were not only highly intelligent but they were also said to be physically attractive.
Abelard wrote,
Under the pretext of study we spent our hours in the happiness of love, and learning held out to us the secret opportunities that our passion craved. Our speech was more of love than of the books which lay open before us; our kisses far outnumbered our reasoned words. Our hands sought less the book than each other's bosoms - love drew our eyes together far more than the lesson drew them to the pages of our text.

So he could always be near Heloise, Abelard told Fulbert that his living quarters were not conducive to study. He explained that if he could board in Fulbert’s house it would be both good for his and Heloise’s studies. Not suspecting that a love affair was going on between this great scholar and his niece, Fulbert agreed to Abelard’s request.
Once Abelard moved into Fulbert’s house, the affair was discovered. He wrote,
Oh, how great was the uncle's grief when he learned the truth, and how bitter was the sorrow of the lovers when we were forced to part!
Heloise and Abelard continued to rendezvous in secret until Heloise learned that she was pregnant. With Abelard’s help, Heloise fled to the home of his sister. She stayed there until she had her baby, a son which she named Astrolabe. Maybe because she was young and imaginative or eccentric like many learned people, she decided to name her child after an instrument used to study the stars.
Peter Abelard finally got around to apologizing to Fulbert and asking for Heloise’s hand in marriage. Fulbert had no objections to the marriage because he wanted the scandal to blow over as soon as possible, but Heloise did. She felt that since Abelard was such an influential person in the academic world, marriage would cut into the time he needed to devote to study and teaching. He would never be able to reach heights of even more greatness if he had a wife and child chained to him. Abelard continued to press Heloise about the matter of matrimony. She finally gave in. Leaving little Astrolabe with his sister, Abelard and Heloise secretly married. They would never see their child again because Abelard would make a decision that would separate them from their baby and each other forever.
Abelard took Heloise to a convent believing this was in their best interests. He was going to go back for her, but when Fulbert heard that his niece was in a convent, he thought Abelard had forced her to go there with the intension of abandoning her. He decided to get revenge. The scandal had become the talk of Paris and France. One night while Abelard lay asleep some thugs that Fulbert hired were let into the rooms where Abelard was staying by one of his servants. The thugs castrated Abelard while he was asleep!
It was now over for Heloise and Abelard as far as being together as man and wife in the normal sense. Abelard’s career was also in effect finished. In the years to come, he would regain some of his fame, but it would be a torturous climb back to some normalcy. The story of the attack of Abelard spread like wildfire throughout Europe.
Heloise and Abelard reluctantly married the church becoming a nun and a monk, but they did not fully love or embrace their decision. They still loved each other. Even though because of his horrible fate, Peter seemed to be cold at times toward Heloise in some letters he continued write to her and love her. For 20 years the lovers corresponded while being cloistered. Their letters were passionate, but as time moved on their love seemed to reach a higher level, that of the spiritual. Peter would refer to her as his sister. He continued to study, learn and debate, deliberately getting on the nerves of some of the other monks with his controversial ideas.Most of Heloise's and Abelard's love letters have been lost, but the few that still exist show a love and devotion that is alien to our culture and age. Christina Nehring wrote in a 2005 New York Times essay about these quintessential lovers of the Middle Ages and all time that,
The story of Abelard and Heloise hardly resonates with the spirit of our age. Not least, its origins in the classroom offend: teachers, we know, are not supposed to fall in love with their students. Heloise, moreover, is no feminist heroine, despite having been one of the best educated women of her age and writing some of its most affecting prose. Nobody who takes the veil on the command of her husband and swears ''complete obedience'' to him can hope to sneak into the bastion of feminism.
Today, even the high romance of the couple's liaison strikes us as foreign: all that sacrifice and intensity! We live in a time of broad antiromanticism when teenagers, according to The Times Magazine, have given up on relationships altogether and adults write to the editor to salute their wisdom. ''Romance?'' scoffed one correspondent. It's just ''an excuse . . . to work off sexual energy.''
Small wonder, in this climate, that the anguish Abelard and Heloise suffered for each other renders them even more suspect. What with safe sex, prenuptial agreements and emotional air cushions of every stripe, we have almost managed to riskproof our relationships. The notion that passion might comprise not only joy but pain, not only self-realization but self-abandonment, seems archaic. To admire, as an early-20th-century biographer of Abelard and Heloise does, the ''beauty of souls large enough to be promoted to such sufferings'' seem downright perverse. And yet there's a grandeur to high-stakes romance, to self-sacrifice, that's missing from our latex-love culture -- and it's a grandeur we perhaps crave to recover.
When I ponder the love of Heloise and Abelard, I think, ‘Boy! The love we have lost!

Before she died, Heloise said that she wanted to be laid to rest beside her husband who had passed away years before. Severed from each other in life, Heloise and Abelard were finally reunited in death. This is their tomb in Paris. There is a little uncertainty as to if this is the actual final resting place of the lovers.
The following short video is called The Song of Abelard and was made by someone who lives in Turkey. The music in the clip is by a Turkish composer named Ismail Sezen.
One of Heloise’s letters to Abelard can be read here.
Click here and when you scroll down you can see a postmodern artistic representation of the two lovers which is symbolic of their erotic love, eruditeness, and their final fate which was celibacy in the church.
Two years ago a book called Heloise and Abelard: A New Biography was published. I have read it and recommend it for those who want to learn in detail about these two real life lovers.







